The latest tax figures released by the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) have revealed a concerning trend for the state’s cannabis industry. The first quarter of 2023 witnessed a staggering 18.8% decline in cannabis excise taxes, marking the seventh consecutive quarter of falling tax revenue for the sector. This decline in revenue is just one of the many challenges the industry has been grappling with in recent years.
Falling Tax Revenue and Shrinking Market
California’s legal cannabis market has been experiencing a continuous shrinkage, with total cannabis sales in the first quarter of 2023 down by 1.4% compared to the previous quarter. This decline in revenue has put significant strain on farmers, distributors, and retailers. Farmers have long reported being shortchanged by distributors, who, in turn, claim that they are not being paid by retailers. As a result, the entire supply chain has been affected, leading to dwindling tax revenues.
Marc Hauser, a cannabis consultant and former attorney specializing in the industry, attributes the downturn to two main factors. Firstly, the decrease in consumer spending following the end of the pandemic, when cannabis sales were higher. Secondly, the industry continues to grapple with the burden of high tax rates, which have impeded growth and profitability.
Hirsh Jain, a cannabis consultant at Ananda Strategy and vice chair of the California Cannabis Chamber of Commerce, points out that the falling tax revenue reflects the failure to establish retail cannabis access in new parts of the state. Over 60% of counties and cities have banned legal pot stores, resulting in a limited number of markets and creating favorable conditions for illegal stores to thrive. Policymakers must understand that increasing taxes on the already burdened stores will only hasten the collapse of California’s legal cannabis market.
Missed Tax Payments and Bailout Concerns
Compounding the industry’s challenges is the recent increase in retailers failing to pay their excise taxes. The responsibility for paying excise taxes was shifted from distribution companies to retail stores, resulting in a significant number of stores unable to cover their tax obligations. According to CDTFA data, 265 retailers missed the May 1 deadline for excise tax payments, amounting to a 9% shortfall in total excise taxes due. As a consequence, these retailers now face a 50% penalty and are at risk of going out of business.
The dire financial situation has led Jonatan Cvetko, executive director of the United Cannabis Business Association, to call for a potential bailout. Cvetko suggests more favorable tax payment plans and relaxation of the 50% penalty to prevent the collapse of California’s retail side of the cannabis industry.
One of California’s largest cannabis distribution companies, Herbl, is facing severe financial challenges, further threatening the industry’s stability. The company, which claimed to have delivered $700 million worth of cannabis to 1,000 retailers, has reportedly experienced payment delays and partial payments to suppliers. Major brands have canceled contracts with Herbl, urging retailers to stop making payments to the troubled distributor. This development has raised concerns that the outstanding debts of Herbl could have a detrimental impact on the brands associated with the company.
The declining tax revenue, shrinking market, missed tax payments, and the financial troubles of major distributor Herbl paint a worrisome picture for California’s cannabis industry. Policymakers must address the uneven rollout of legal cannabis, provide support to struggling retailers, and consider potential measures like tax payment plan revisions to prevent the collapse of the state’s legal cannabis market. The industry’s stability and growth are crucial not only for the economic well-being of cannabis operators but also for the state’s overall revenue. Without swift action and strategic reforms, California’s cannabis industry could face further setbacks, jeopardizing its potential to contribute to the state’s economy and undermining the progress made in the legalization and regulation of cannabis. As stakeholders assess the situation, it is imperative to find solutions that foster a thriving and sustainable cannabis market while addressing the concerns of farmers, distributors, retailers, and consumers alike. The future of California’s cannabis industry hangs in the balance, and proactive measures are needed to navigate these challenging times and ensure its long-term success.
Leave a Reply